top of page
images.jpg

Initial Analysis 

Our initial research was to decide what is the best way to lift the quarter. We did some initial heat, work, and energy calculations. In addition, we had to determine which idea would be the most effective in raising the quarter.

Initial Analysis: Inner_about

Initial Designs 

Initial Analysis: Testimonial
Gears

Spring - Launcher

A quarter would sit on top of a spring that is initially in equilibrium. The spring is compressed by a fluid being heated inside a chamber. Then, allow pressure to build in the chamber again. Lastly, release the pressure instantaneously shooting the quarter 2 meters into the air. 


Some potential fluids we can use for the chamber include air, water, and alcohol. We wanted to find the perfect fluid to use, one that has a low boiling point and low specific heat capacity.


Boiling Point & Specific Heat Capacity 

Air = x°C, 1.020 J/g°C

Water = 100 °C, 4.184 J/g°C

Alcohol = 78.37 °C, 2.460 J/g°C


Looking at the above numbers we decided it would be best to use air since it is already in the gas phase, and it has the lowest specific heat capacity and it is readily available.


Find: Q

Knowns - Gas:

K (spring constant) = 1N/m

Energy From Candle = 233 J

Spring potential energy: U = 1/2kx^2

233 = ½(1)(x^2)

So the displacement of our spring has to be 15.26cm. This is a very large displacement. So this idea might not be as feasible, because of the energy required to return the spring to its equilibrium position.​​



61A1yiO9xvL._SY355_.jpg

Stirling Engine

A Stirling engine uses the expansion and compression of a gas to create movement or work. There is a closed cylinder with a constant volume of gas. A heat source, such as a candle, heats the cylinder which expands the gas. This expansion moves a piston until the piston reaches the heat sink. The purpose of the heat sink is to absorb the heat, so that the gas can cool and compress, thus creating a cycle of expansion and compression. The most efficient Stirling Engines work based on a large temperature gradient.

Mass of quarter = 5.67 g

Weight of quarter = (.00567 kg) * (9.81 m/s^2) = .0556 N

Work to move quarter up 2m = (.00567 kg) * (9.81 m/s^2) * (2 m) = .1112 J

To lift quarter up, stirling engine must produce a lifting force greater than .0556 N


The force the engine can produce will depend on the heat source, gas, the cylinder size, and the weight of the piston and flywheel. The heat source is the candle, and for gas, we plan to use air, unless we can get a hold of a gas with a lower specific heat than that of air, since then it would expand quicker. We do not want a large cylinder since a larger volume of gas takes longer to heat up. Force of the engine will be F = ma, where m is the mass of the piston, and a is the acceleration of the piston, or in other words, the expanding gas. We do not have the values for the cylinder size, the volume of gas, or mass of piston, but we can derive formulas to calculate the force the engine produces in terms of q, the candle heat.

F_engine = Fexpansion - friction

Friction = (μ static) * (piston mass) * (g)

F_expansion = pressure * Area

Pressure = RT/V

q = m * c * (delta T) c = 1.020 J/g°C

Before the piston can move, temperature must raise high enough so that force of the pressure breaks the frictional force of the piston.

Capture.JPG

Cannon

By composing a cannon like a barrel containing a specific fluid, we can rest a quarter inside the cannon which ultimately acts as a cannonball. Where the fluid inside the barrel would be heated by the candle and build up the pressure. Once enough pressure is built, then the coin would launch into the air by flicking the cannon the pressure that built inside would shoot the coin two meters in the air vertically. This method is very similar to the spring method, but the quarter is placed directly above the pressure chamber instead of on top of a spring. 


The below calculations show how much force is required to launch the quarter. 

ΣF = Fqcosϴ - Fg = 0

Fq must be much greater than Fg in order launch the coin

Mass of quarter = 5.670 grams = 0.00567kg

Fg = m*g =  (0.00567kg)(9.8 m /s2) = 0.055566 N

If placed at ϴ = 20°

Fg = Fqcosϴ →0.055566 N = Fqcos(20) → Fq =  0.055566 N/ cos(20) → 0.59132N​


Using → F = ma,  (where we need to find acceleration to know F) we can find the force. 

Initial Heat & Work Calculations 

How much energy is theoretically produced from a candle ?

Based on online research we obtained the following constants for paraffin wax: density of wax is 900 kgm3, energy content of paraffin wax is 42 kJg, and the approximate dimensions of a candle, which correspond to a diameter of 38 mm, and a height of 16 mm.

The volume based on the precious dimensions is 18.14 cm3, this gives us an approximate mass of 16.326 g, and a theoretical energy of 685.692 kJ.

How much energy is realistically produced from the candle? 

Based on an experiment from Instructables “Measuring the Energy Output of a Tea Light” the following temperature readings were obtained over a period of 25 minutes.


Time (min) & Temperature 

0 ...... 14°C

5 ...... 28°C

10 ...... 36°C

15 ..... 44°C

20 ..... 48°C

25 ..... 53°C

We can use the following equation to calculate the heat from the candle: Q=mcT

Water has a specific heat capacity of 4.181 JgC, given a total temperature change of 39C, which results in a total heat of 32611.8 J.  From the obtained values and the time the experiment was conducted we obtained an average of 21.74 W of power.

Given that a tea light candle burns for an average of 3 hours, we calculated the theoretical power to be  63.49 W. Comparing both values we obtain that the candle is about 34% efficient.  This means from the total energy produced, 685.692kJ, we can only use about 233.135kJ to help us accomplish our task.

Which design is the most efficient to raise the quarter the desired height? 

The best design to raise the quarter is the Stirling engine. With the spring we are not allowed to use any potential energy the spring might store when compressed. So we would need to use the candle heat to compress the spring and build pressure again to release the quarter. Also according to our calculations above it can be seen that for the spring to launch the quarter 2 meters it has to displace 15cm. This displacement is not possible with the little energy produced from a candle. The same problem occurs with the cannon. We doubt there would be enough energy to build sufficient pressure to launch the quarter. This is why we have decided to build a Stirling Engine.

What materials & supplies are needed to construct a Stirling Engine? 

There are a few key components required to make a Stirling Engine: a displacer and piston. The displacer is the chamber the heated air travels through, and the piston moves up and down causing motion. It is also very important to make sure all the chambers are properly sealed, so no air escapes. We will be using steel wool for our displacer material, and a soda can build the body of the engine. We also plan to make the displacer and piston in the same chamber to help with any heat loss that may occur.

Initial Analysis: FAQ

©2018 by The little candle that could. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page